A Simple Twist of Fate (Steve Martin)

(Amazon UK link)

We first saw the film ‘A Simple Twist of Fate’ about nine and a half years ago, so it was definitely time for a re-watch. We had forgotten almost everything about the plot, other than that a single man (Steve Martin) adopts a small child. But we could see that from the cover. The other thing I recalled was that we had been expecting something amusing, as we thought it was billed as a comedy - only to find that it was quite disturbing in places, and really not the kind of film that could be classed that way.

I had not recalled the opening scenes at all. Michael - played by Steve Martin - is a music teacher. We see him conducting a choir, in stark contrast to the traumatic scene that follows with his wife. The next time we meet him, some years later, he has become a recluse, and something of a miser, in a cabin away from the town. He works with his hands, making furniture, and is evidently quite talented at what he does.

Meanwhile there’s a political sideline, involving two sleazy brothers, one of whom has an illegitimate child that nobody (other than his brother) knows about. The child’s mother is a drug addict, and when her financial support becomes less and less, she takes drastic action which leads to tragedy.

The main part of the story involves the gradual humanising of Michael, as he figures out ways to look after the toddler Mathilda, some of them quite unconventional. There are one or two light-hearted scenes, a few places where we smiled, and overall a heartwarming storyline, albeit with fighting, drama, theft and a difficult court case.

Steve Martin carries this story, with a mixture of poignancy and his excellent comic timing that comes through in his facial expressions and some slick movement. It’s not a funny film - I realised that we had been confused because the back of the DVD case refers to Martin as a comedy actor - but it does have some very warm-hearted scenes, and a satisfying ending, even if preceded by a somewhat unlikely climax, given the timing.

Mathilda is played by several young actresses at different ages, but the one with the most to do is Alana Austin, who is Mathilda at ten. She is excellent in this role - believable, passionate, and ultimately very likeable. Her biological father John (Gabriel Byrne) is done well too, as someone easily led, after power and riches; not a bad person, but extremely self-centered.

I wondered, in the first twenty minutes or so, whether we had made a mistake in choosing this film, but it does get better; the early sections are necessary to set the background for the story, and they’re probably all too realistic, unfortunately. I’m glad we continued watching, as the main part of the story was very watchable, paced just right, and - since we didn’t recall the ending at all - quite tense at times.

Apparently the plot is based on the classic novel ‘Silas Marner’, one I haven’t read. At times it reminded me of the children’s classic novel ‘Heidi’.

‘A Simple Twist of Fate’ is rated PG in the UK, which I feel is too lenient; the US rating pf PG-13 is more appropriate, as there are some quite unpleasant scenes, and the storyline is not at all appropriate to younger children.

Recommended to adults and older teens.

Review copyright 2021 Sue's DVD Reviews